Overview
Design and execute a “New Vision for Energy” campaign to encourage a national market-based transition to alternative energy sources. Harness multiple messages tailored to different audiences that embed the climate change issue in a larger set of co-benefit narratives, such as: reducing U.S. dependency on Middle East oil (national security); penetrating global export markets with American innovations (U.S. stature); boosting U.S. job growth (jobs); and cutting local air pollution (health).
Recent posts
[postsincategory#37]
Participants
Tov Anderson
William Becker
Thomas Brewer
Carolyn Brouillard
John Bodt
Mohamed Elkeiy
David Grant
Bob Henson
Kris Holstrom
Andrew Huemmler
Marty Krasney
Clayt Lauter
Emily Levin
James Martin-Schramm
Evonne Marzouk
Lauren McGregor
Samuel Missimer
Christopher Nelson
Stephen Nodvin
Michael Northcott
Stuart Price
William Rauckhorst
Dan Richardson
Frederick Stoss
Wood Turner
Aaron Viles
News
Eileen Claussen, President of the Pew Center on Global Climate Change talks at Yale F&ES about the need for America to show leadership on the climate issue, and offers a comprehensive energy plan to reduce carbon emmissions. Video - 45 minutes
Objective
- More compelling rationales for action. The climate change issue does not yet supply sufficient rationale for action on its own. Rather, it needs to be packaged with a larger constellation of issues that connect more easily with people’s salient concerns today and their incentives to pursue profitable opportunities.
- Relationship to other initiatives.Initiatives linking climate change to energy issues are already underway, such as the National Commission on Energy Policy, the Energy Future Coalition Securing America’s Future Energy, and Set America Free. These other initiatives need to be diagnosed before launching another effort: Have they been successful so far, and if not, why not? Do they weight climate change heavily enough in their actions, communications and policy prescriptions? Should any incremental effort be directed toward reinforcing these other initiatives underway or launching a separate new campaign?
- Positive vision. Sustain a positive, can-do tone in this campaign
to the extent possible. - Localize where possible.Many of the messages contained in the larger campaign will lend themselves to identifying and communicating local risks and benefits.
- Leverage-point strategy and grassroots.A leveraged strategy focusing on political elites and opinion influencers and a grassroots campaign are equally critical. Some are skeptical that a true grassroots “public education” campaign on climate change is really possible, given resource constraints, the complexity of the issue and other factors.
- Use the “purple” approach (i.e., combining red and blue states).The bipartisan roots of environmental progress could be highlighted much more effectively in support of this campaign, both amidst the general public and elites. Those who know environmental history tend to be aware that leaders in both parties were critical to earlier successes, but the long shadow of recent polarization may have eclipsed this fact.
- Highlight market-based mechanisms.One virtue of incorporating a cap-and-trade system into any proposed policy fixes for climate change is that it builds on the successful model of the acid rain program that was created under a Republican administration (George H.W. Bush), which could help moderate the partisanship associated with such a proposed policy if highlighted properly.
- Clean coal as part of the equation.Some argue that the United States needs a major effort on clean coal and sequestration specifically to reduce the sense of economic risk that has led the coal industry to be generally opposed to climate change action.
Related initiatives
- The Apollo Alliance is a broad coalition within the labor, environmental, business, urban, and faith communities in support of good jobs and energy independence. It has been endorsed by the AFL-CIO and 23 international labor unions as well as a majority of national environmental organizations. The Alliance is developing public education campaigns and communications strategies to link allies and build a new national constituency for a bold, broad based, and immediate program of public policy to achieve energy independence. The Apollo Alliance is pursuing a $300 billion, public-private program to create three million new, clean energy jobs to free America from foreign oil dependence in ten years. It is a program that reinvests in the competitiveness of American industry, rebuilds our cities, creates good jobs for working families, and ensures good stewardship of both the economy and our natural environment.
It is a joint project of the Institute for America’s Future and the Center on Wisconsin Strategy.
- Climate Counts is a new non-profit initiative spearheaded by Stonyfield Farm and Clean Air-Cool Planet, with support from GreenOrder (a sustainability strategy firm). It focuses on building a unique tool that will enable mainstream consumers who are concerned about global climate change to use their purchasing power to support companies and brands that have initiated enterprise action on the issue.
- The National Commission on Energy Policy is a a bipartisan group of 20 of the nation’s leading energy experts – representing the highest ranks of industry, government, academia, labor, consumer and environmental protection – which joined together in 2004. The Commission will focus, in particular, on three critical long-term issues: oil security, climate change, and energy infrastructure adequacy and siting. The Commission is funded by the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation and its partners.
- The Green Machines Tour is an educational campaign to showcase fuel-efficient vehicle technologies being made in the nation’s heartland, and to build awareness of new policy opportunities that can further enhance the industry’s competitiveness. Launched in August 2004, the tour brings together local UAW officers, environmental organizations, auto industry representatives, and elected officials to promote fuel-efficient technologies and policies that can ensure that future advanced vehicle technologies are produced in the U.S., keeping the domestic automobile industry competitive.
- The Energy Future Coalition is a broad-based, nonpartisan alliance that seeks to bridge the differences among business, labor, and environmental groups and identify energy policy options with broad political support. The coalition aims to bring about changes in U.S. energy policy to address the economic, security and environmental challenges related to the production and use of fossil fuels with a compelling new vision of the economic opportunities that will be created by the transition to a new energy economy.
- Rocky Mountain Institute - Rocky Mountain Institute (RMI), a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, was established in 1982 by resource analysts L. Hunter Lovins and Amory B. Lovins. What began as a small group of colleagues focusing on energy policy has since grown into a broad-based institution with approximately forty full-time staff, an annual budget of nearly $6 million (over half of it earned through programmatic enterprise), and a global reach. RMI brings a unique perspective to resource issues, guided by the following core principles: Advanced Resource Productivity, Systems Thinking, Positive Action, Market-Oriented Solutions, End-Use/Least-Cost Approach, Biological Insight, Corporate Transformation, The Pursuit of Interconnections, Natural Capitalism
- Securing America’s Future Energy is an action-oriented, nonpartisan organization which aims to reduce America’s dependence on oil, addressing business and technology, politics and advocacy, and public education and media.
- The Set America Free Coalition is a consortium of prominent individuals and non-profit organizations concerned about the security and economic implications of America’s growing dependence on foreign oil. The coalition, organized by the Institute for the Analysis of Global Security (IAGS), promotes a blueprint which spells out practical ways in which real progress toward energy security can be made over the next several years.
- United States Climate Action Partnership (USCAP) is a group of businesses and leading environmental organizations that have come together to call on the federal government to quickly enact strong national legislation to require significant reductions of greenhouse gas emissions. USCAP has issued a landmark set of principles and recommendations to underscore the urgent need for a policy framework on climate change.



2 comments
March 3rd, 2007 at 1:02 am
Frank Zaski
Here are some thoughts on global warming communications and individual actions. Not a campaign jsut yet. But a start.
The media is doing a good job trying to communicate the macro causes and effects of global warming. However, some people may have a hard time relating to environmental problems that seem far away at the earth’s poles or at distant power plants. One approach is to bring it into people’s everyday lives. Like politics, make global warming local, personal, moral and a pocket book issue. Individual actions are also suggested. Some ideas:
Increase Understanding and Action
1. Make the impact of global warming more local in communications Provide people with data as to how global warming will affect their state, city and their families directly. In addition to flooded property, severe weather, increased health issues, disruption of crops, forests and animals, here are a few examples of disruption at the state level. Michigan for example:
· Increased temperatures will accelerate air pollution and ozone causing more health issues.
· The nature of our forests will change with northern species being replaced with grasslands and southern Michigan type trees. “Up-North” may look more like Ingham County in 50 years.
· Certain crops will be able to grow further north, while others such as cherries and blueberries may disappear from the Lower Peninsula.
· Less snow and ice will greatly deter winter sports such as ice fishing, skiing, snowmobiling and reducing tourism and related jobs. This is already happening.
· Water levels may continue to drop and water temperatures will rise. Shipping and boating will be hurt and many Michigan waters may no longer support trout, muskie, whitefish, walleye and other cold water fish, again hurting tourism and jobs. (I have detailed sources for all of these.)
The Union of Concerned Scientists has a lot of state specific impacts. http://www.ucsusa.org/greatlakes/glregionmic.html As well as the National Wildlife Federation http://www.nwf.org/globalwarming/states.cfm the EPA http://yosemite.epa.gov/oar/globalwarming.nsf/UniqueKeyLookup/SHSU5BUTCC/$File/mi_impct.pdf and the Michigan Environmental Council http://www.mecprotects.org/pr3_22_06.htm
2. Make the impact of global warming more individual in communications:
a. It’s hard to relate to the US federal budget deficit of $9 trillion, but breaking it down to $30,000 per person makes it more understandable.
b. Per Carbonfund.org, the average American is responsible for 10 tons of direct emissions, including your home, car and air travel, but a whopping 24 tons of CO2 per capita when you include your impact from purchasing clothes, food, using roads and all the other emissions throughout the economy.
3. Make the causes of and solutions for global warming more specific:
a. Explain the connection between an individual’s actions, power consumption and greenhouse gas emissions. Give examples of how our everyday activities impact global warming.
b. For example, the electricity needed to burn one 100 watt incandescent light bulb for six hours a day for a year requires burning about 180 pounds of coal which emits 300 pounds of CO2 into the atmosphere.
c. Replacing that bulb with a 26 watt compact fluorescent light bulb will save about 130 pounds of coal, 220 pounds of CO2 and $16.00 a year in electric bills.
4. Make the IMPACTS of global warming individual pocketbook issues:
a. Flooding of property in some areas
b. Increased health issues and costs
c. Increased A/C costs
d. Disruption of crops, forests, animals, tourism, etc.
e. It may be much better for the economy if we fight global warming rather than allow it.
5. Make the SOLUTIONS for global warming individual pocketbook issues:
a. In addition to addressing the above impacts, individuals can fight global warming and save money at the same time in their households. For example in Michigan:
b. By cutting your car’s gasoline consumption by 20%, you can save $400 and 3,000 lbs. of CO2. (Through driving less, using better driving techniques and vehicle maintenance. Buying a more fuel efficient car will save even more.)
c. By cutting your heating use by 20%, you can save $300 and 3,000 lbs. of CO2. (Dial down the thermostat, insulate, calk, maintain furnace)
d. By cutting your electricity use by 20%, you can save $100 and 2,000 lbs. of CO2. (Turn up the A/C, use compact fluorescent light bulbs, install Energy Star appliances)
e. Altogether, you can save $800 on your energy bills and 8,000 lbs. of CO2 a year.
6. Broaden the impact and solutions of global warming into social justice issues. For example, by conserving energy and cutting pollution and greenhouse gasses, we:
a. Have more money to spend on better things (education? health care? 401k?)
b. Reduce fuel prices for all of us, especially the neediest (less demand = lower prices?)
c. Prolong the time before fuels are much less affordable – especially for our poorest
d. Allow more time for alternative fuels and renewable energy to be implemented
e. Reduce balance of payments and reliance on imported fuels
f. Reduce ozone, asthma and other health problems, particularly for the uninsured
7. Make the causes and effects of global warming more visual. Communicate better to visual learners and all of us by showing the many causes and solutions in graphic form.
Some Global Warming Reduction Actions for Individuals
The following are some thoughts on what an individual can do to fight global warming.
8. Set a Good Example
a. Do all you can to reduce greenhouse emission at home, work, school and in the car through energy conservation and efficiency and using renewable energy if possible.
b. Encourage and help others to do the same.
c. Stop reading this paper for 2 minutes. Get up from your chair and turn the thermostat down to 68 degrees or lower (in winter) or up to 78 degrees (in summer) and turn off all un-needed lights. Welcome back!
9. Contact the Media In addition to letters to the editors, contact newspaper editors and writers, magazines, local and national radio and TV stations and network newsrooms and other media:
a. Ask them for more stories on global warming, what is happening politically, what other states and countries are doing, what we can do as individual and collectively to slow it (emphasis on solutions), success stories, etc.
b. Suggest stories to the above groups by supplying ideas, resources from the web, etc.
10. Contact People of Influence Ask ministers, managers, teachers and others to promote global warming reduction. Provide them with appropriate materials about the impacts, causes and solutions.
11. Contact Companies Contact store managers or even the company’s top management if you see there is an opportunity for them to save energy and lessen global warming emissions. Call or mail letters (US Postal System) to corporate CEO’s and CFO’s directly (their offices are more likely to take action):
a. Ask auto companies to produce more efficient cars and practice energy and CO2 saving practices in their facilities
b. Ask utilities to reduce smokestack emissions, use renewable energy sources and encourage energy efficiency among their customers (communicate methods and offer incentives).
c. Ask ExxonMobil to work on solutions rather than hiding the problem.
d. Ask lighting stores to encourage them to use compact fluorescent light bulbs (CFLs). (Ask Home Depot and Lowe’s why they promote CFLs but do not use them in their own lighting department display lamps.)
e. Contact stores (malls, schools, offices and other) that are too warm in the winter. Many retail stores keep their thermostats (winter setting) at 72º while most of us keep our homes at 68º. Ask them to dial down to 68º or less to save fuel.
f. In warm weather, ask building managers to “dial up” the A/C in order to stop wasting electricity and creating CO2. And if you see a store’s parking lot lights on during the day, ask them to turn them off.
g. Environmental groups can provide company addresses, web sites, CEO and CFO names, talking points, sample letters, etc.
12. Contact Governments
a. The federal government may be global warming impotent until there is an administration change. In the mean time, concentrate efforts on state and local governments
b. Many state governments are taking charge in reducing CO2, improved building standards, promoting energy efficiency programs, regulating utility emissions and renewable energy programs, etc.
c. Contact governors, energy offices, state legislators and local government leaders to encourage global warming reduction programs.
13. Support federal and state gasoline tax increases with an offset in other taxes or the additional taxes earmarked for alternative fuel research or highway construction. A higher gasoline price motivates drivers to buy fuel efficient vehicles and adopt fuel saving driving behaviors (For example, car pooling, better vehicle maintenance, less speeding and jack rabbit acceleration and more demand for and usage of public transportation)
14. Ask your employer, place of worship and local school district, city and county if they have an energy efficiency plan.
15. Support and campaign for federal, state and local candidates who promote positive environmental actions.
16. Ask environmental, religious and other groups to ask their members to commit to reducing global warming. Ask them to have their members sign a pledge that they will implement and follow energy efficiency practices, promote such practices to at least two other people.
17. Ask organizations to turn global warming reduction into a movement. Ask them to:
a. Provide a vision of what global warming reduction will look like
b. Let individuals know they are not victims but are very enabled to make an impact in their lives, families, homes, cars, place of work and beyond
c. Provide tools, success stories and encouragement to influence them to make change.
18. Show Appreciation If someone or organization does something to reduce global warming, show appreciation. Call them or send them a note. Perhaps environmental groups could have an honor roll where members could post their appreciation.
April 6th, 2007 at 2:31 pm
Richard Jordan
Excellent points, I will see how to bring them into the conference that I am charing at the UN in September for 3000 NGOs on climate change.
That’s one way!
Richard Jordan